যারে দেখতে নারি, তার চলন বাঁকা অথবা সামির আমিনের চোখে ইসলামপন্থা

Tareq-ul Huda

September 2, 2023

যত বড় মার্কসীয় চিন্তাবিদের উদাহরণই টানি না কেন, তার ভিতরে এই বৈশিস্ট্য থাকবেই। অনেক উদাহরণ ঘেঁটে ক্লান্ত হবার চাইতে, আলোচনার পরিসরের দিকে তাকিয়ে উল্লেখযোগ্য কাউকে মডেল হিসাবে নেয়াই উত্তম। তাই ডাকসাইটে মার্ক্সবাদী তাত্ত্বিক সদ্য প্রয়াত সামির আমীনকেই এবারে বেছে নিলাম। তাত্ত্বিক আলোচনার দিকে না গিয়ে আমিনের চিন্তার মূল সমস্যার দিকটি কাঁচাভাবে ধরার নিমিত্তে কয়েকটি সাক্ষাৎকার এবং বক্তব্য ছেঁকে নিলাম। মজার বিষয় আমাদের দেশের মার্ক্সবাদী তাত্ত্বিকরা ধর্মের আলোচনা করেন মোটামুটি একই ছকে। বলাই বাহুল্য, আমি মার্কসীয় চিন্তার এই ছককে একেবারেই অসাড় না ভাবলেও, তার পদ্ধতিকে ক্ষেত্রবিশেষে ভুল, সমস্যাকীর্ন এবং ফলাফলকে যথেস্ট অসম্পূর্ন মনে করি।

Read More

The Taliban, Near Victory: Winning Against Empire as Covid -19 Looms*

“The withdrawal of foreign forces, in excess of 130,000 at its height in 2014, if completed, would make the Taliban the most potent and formidable political and military force in Afghanistan; leaving it in the position to determine the political future of the nation, along with their primary sponsors, Pakistan and the Gulf Arab states, particularly Saudi Arabia and Qatar, as well as Iran, which also, surprisingly, contributed significantly to Taliban military efforts in the west and northwest, coordinated by the Pasdaran/IRGC/Quds Force from 2010-2016. The Taliban insurgency has thus become one of the longest and most successful insurgencies in modern world history, as well as in the five centuries of Muslim resistance to western imperialism.”

Read More

On Political Amnesia: Afghan and American Elections Overlook Civilian Killings

“President Ghani was forced to fire NDS spy chief Masoum Stanikzai over the murders, marking the first known repercussion the NDS has faced since Ghani took office. The president’s sudden "shock" about civilian casualties is all theatrics, as this is not the first, second or 20th time government killings have taken place. His gesture seemed to be more of a campaign stunt, rather than a substantial change in policy, as Ghani has been confronted with similar stories throughout his tenure as president, which he consistently ignored.”

Read More

The Tariq Ramadan Case: A Comprehensive Review

"In what follows, I suggest that the truly odd legislative developments in the Ramadan case—the justice of exception we are witnessing at work, which will be addressed in the second half of this article—may be explained at least partially by the national (and to a lesser extent European) context in which they are occurring: a culture characterized by intense and pervasive Islamophobia in general (whose varied manifestations and links to France’s colonial history are beyond the scope of this piece) and more specifically, an already old French campaign to eliminate Ramadan from the intellectual, social, political and religious landscape of the nation."

Read More

Distorting Hamas's Origins: A Response to Mehdi Hasan

"This article argues that Hasan’s narrative is not only an impetuous and intellectually dishonest account of a complicated history, but also conceptually flawed. By presenting Islamists as terrorist fanatics created by the very enemy they are fighting, Hasan effaces the crucial role of Islamists in the movement against Israeli colonization, and understates their popular support. Elementary knowledge of the history of the Palestinian cause and Islamism in the Middle East refutes these hasty claims."

Read More

A Preliminary Enquiry Concerning Aunties in Contemporary Understanding

"A specter is haunting South Asian diasporic youth—the specter of the Aunty. All the diasporic youth of South Asia have entered into a holy alliance to exorcise this specter in order to disclose their own modern being. Reviled in her multiple forms, the Aunty is, as Maria Qamar argues, ‘a cross-cultural phenomenon that isn’t limited to a family member; she could be a neighbour, a family friend, or just some lady on the bus who wants to throw some casual black magic your way.’ Magical and entrancing, the Aunty can indeed be found everywhere, awaiting her coming exorcism."

Read More